September 3, 2016: Last Day of Miami Seaquarium Shows for the Year




Victoria, BC was a late addition (as were many other locations) to this international demonstration organized by Shut Down Palace in support of Lolita Tokitae’s retirement, We would like September 3, 2016  to be the last show ever for Lolita Tokitae, because she has been allowed to retire after 46 years of captivity and exploitation, not because she died alone, far from her family, captive and exploited in a substandard tank.  But this is still only a hope, although Orca Network and the Center for Whale Research have developed a feasible and complete plan to return Lolita Tokitae to her home waters with human care for as long as that is needed.

On September 3, supporters of the plan were again on the streets of Victoria BC, where Lolita’s other still swims offshore, handing out information and gathering signatures on a letter to Parques Reunidos, which owns palace Entertainment, which owns the Miami Seaquairum. (All of that is owned by Arle Capital.)

Mr. Fernado Eiroa was CEO of Palace Entertainment from 2007 until February 2016, when he replaced  Yann Calliere as CEO of Parques Reunidos. There is no public information on who has replaced him as CEO of Palace Entertainment.

Fernando succeeds Yann Caillère (63) who, after two successful years of leading Parques Reunidos, decided to step down, given the longer term commitment required in the context of a targeted IPO of the company.”

Here’s hoping Parques’ IPO has the same trajectory as Sea World’s recent profit picture, as people realize the atrocity that orca and cetacean captivity is:

SeaWorld sees profits plunge 84% as customers desert controversial park

 At this time, this blog is the website for the Victoria Orca Festival Society.The letter is here, addressed to the CEO of Arle Capital (it has been sent previously with signatures gathered at 2016 FernFest directly to Arle Capital). The 47 letters from September 3  have been sent via Parques CEO Fernando Eiroa with the cover letter below. Please use the letters  as a template for your own.

September 3, 2016
Victoria Orca Festival Society
Victoria BC Canada

Mr. Fernando Eiroa
CEO, Parques Reunidos Group
Parques Reunidos Servicios Centrales S.A.
Casa de Campo S/N
28011 Madrid, Spain

Greetings, Mr. Eiroa:

Those of us who have asked over many years for the release of the orca Lolita Tokitae (Miami Seaquarium) to a protected sea pen in her home waters note that you are now responsible for Parques Reunidos as a whole, not only Palace Entertainment, your former position.

Enclosed are 47 letters signed by individuals in Victoria, British Columbia, a coastal city where Lolita’s mother still swims off our shores with her family in L pod, and the extended family of the Southern Resident orcas in J, K and L pods.  Theirs is a complex society, with transmission of culture and language and dialect over generations. The Southern Resident may range over 100 miles in a day.

The Miami Seaquarium could be at the cutting edge of true marine education, instead of on the post-Blackfish wrong side of history, by allowing Lolita to retire and at least contact her family again, if not rejoin them. We are prepared to support her with human assistance and provision of her preferred food for the rest of her life if needed.

Current released video and documents have shown the public that Lolita is not doing well. Please don’t let her die alone in a substandard tank on your watch.

On this last day of Seaquarium shows for this year, we ask that his be the last year of shows for Lolita Tokitae, and that you contact Howard Garrett at Orca Network , 2403 N Bluff Rd, Greenbank, WA 98253, United States in order to implement the Orca Network retirement, transport and sea pen plan.

Diane McNally
President, Victoria Orca Festival Society

Canadian Killer Whale Action Plan: Orcas Need Your Help Before August 14, 2016

Raincoast Conservation Foundation and the Georgia Strait Alliance both have this appeal on their websites and on social media. Both offer helpful background information and both offer assistance with writing a letter and an email.

Raincoast pointed out that an email gets more attention than a petition with multiple names so I did both – signed the petition and wrote an individual email. I hope you will do the same, and write your own email / letter.

I used Raincoast’s foundation letter as a guide and personalized it:

Date: Wed, Jul 27, 2016 at 9:41 PM
Subject: Killer Whale Recovery Plan

Attention SARA and the Honourable Dominic LeBlanc, Minister of Fisheries, Oceans and the Canadian Coast Guard:

A West Coast resident’s expectations regarding the Killer Whale (orca) Action Plan:

1. I have read a couple of these now and there is usually little action involved apart from “more study”. It’s obviously long past time for more impactful action than that. An Action Plan that is specific to the 83 endangered Southern Resident orcas in J, K and L pods is required. The proposed Action Plan treats the  Southern and (200 + ) Northern Residents as one population, when they live in very different areas of the coast with very different challenges.

2.  An adequate food supply must be ensured. Low abundance of Chinook (Spring) salmon means orcas are not getting enough to eat, resulting in their birthrates dropping, and mortality increasing. More Chinook for whales will require closing commercial and recreational Chinook fisheries, and allowing these salmon runs to rebuild.

3.  Boats that closely follow resident killer whales hinder their ability to successfully catch salmon and create ongoing stress. Southern Resident orcas are within 400m of a vessel most of the time during daylight hours from May to September.  Regulations requiring the approach distance to be increased from 100m to at least 200m are urgently needed (matching US regulations), as well as regulations as limiting boat numbers, and/or constraining the viewing times and/or days when boats follow whales are also urgently needed.  To state the obvious, such regulations also require enforcement.

4.  Growing noise levels from ship traffic in the Salish Sea drastically interfere with  hunting, feeding  and communication. Until a Cumulative Effects Assessment is undertaken, and a noise budget completed, no Salish Sea shipping expansions (ergo, increased noise) can be approved.

5.  Funding to monitor and enforce regulations for endangered killer whales must be established.

The 5 above actions are immediate priorities. As well,  longer-term ongoing action that must also start now is needed to address marine pollutants, to create commitments to marine protected areas, to amend the marine mammal regulations, to identify Salish Sea killer whale sanctuaries, and to reduce ship noise.

I look forward to seeing a commitment to action. Don’t let the 83 SRKWs go extinct on your watch.

Diane McNally
Victoria Orca Festival Society
Victoria BC

Are You the Orca People? Yes! Thank You Fernfest!

A great day to wear my Cowichan-knit sweater with the orca design. It’s practically an antique now! Cool but did not rain.  29 letters signed to Arle Capital asking that uber- corporation  to urge their subsidiary Parques Reunidos to urge Palace Entertainment ( the lesser corporation, a subsidiary of Parques Reunidos that owns the Miami Seaquarium)  to retire Lolita Tokitae to a sea pen in the San Juans where her family still swims,  using Orca Network’s safe and realistic plan. Thank you for taking the time, all those who stopped to read and sign.

Feel free to use it yourself!

Sir George Buckley
Chairman, Arle Capital Partners Ltd
12 Charles II Street
London SW1Y 4QU

Re: Parques Reunidos/ Palace Entertainment: Retire Lolita Tokitae to a sea pen in her home waters

Dear Sir George,
I am writing from the coast of Lolita Tokitae’s home waters on a date near the 46th year of her captivity in the Miami Seaquarium. Her tank is barren and substandard. I urge Arle Capital to intervene on Lolita Tokitae’s behalf with Parques Reunidos / Palace Entertainment to allow Lolita to be retired, and returned to a sea pen in her home waters where her mother, Ocean Sun (L25) of L pod of the Southern Residents, still swims, along with Lolita’s extended family, all of whom have been designated under the Endangered Species Act in 2005. On May 11, 2015 the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (US) recognized Lolita as a member of the Southern Resident orca population, and thus endangered as well.

Lolita Tokitae was captured August 8,1970 as part of the Penn Cove Roundup / Massacre from the waters of the San Juan Islands. Her family unit, L-Pod, is a resident fish-eating group of orcas which researchers have documented extensively since 1973. Granny (J2) of J pod, part of the Southern Resident pods (J, K and L) is 104 this year. Lolita is about 48 years old, which is equivalent to human years, so she could have several decades of life remaining, If she is able to return to her native habitat. In the Miami Seaquarium’s tiny tank – not as deep as she is long – she lives a solitary life, performing what must be by now mindless routines daily for a dead fish reward, to entertain tourists who are not all yet aware of the level of cognitive complexity of orcas, though that awareness is growing.

She has endured the tragic suicide of her one-time companion Hugo (an orca also from her home waters, likely a relative with whom she could communicate) who bashed his head into the tank walls more than 30 years ago, in his teen years. She has been without the company of another orca for most of her years of performing at the Miami Seaquarium, although orcas are noted for their lifelong social and family connections.

Return to a sea pen off Orcas Island with human support for as long as she needs is supported by a safe and feasible plan developed by orca experts on staff at Orca Network who have worked with other leaders in the field. Once she regains her physical condition and strength and re-learns the skills necessary for survival, she would be given the opportunity to rejoin her family in the wild. She has not forgotten her family’s language and dialect. If she is unable to rejoin her family after the years spent alone in a tank, she will be cared for and allowed to live as natural a life as possible.

There is no significant risk to Lolita Tokitae in any stage of Orca Network’s proposal for Lolita’s retirement in her home. Remaining in captivity will result in continuing mental and physical stresses and related health issues.

A thorough examination will be conducted by a team of veterinarians and pathologists prior to transport to detect any potential communicable diseases. Assuming there are not, there will be no significant risk to any members of the Southern Resident Community as a result of Lolita Tokitae’s return to her home waters.

Parques Reunidos / Palace Entertainment has an opportunity to be on the right side of history by replacing cruel orca captivity with CGI / virtual reality encounters technology as a truly educational alternative. This decision would bring tremendous positive publicity to the Miami Seaquarium and Palace Entertainment.

I’ve included my return address. Please reply and let me know what you are going to do to get Lolita Tokitae home to the Salish Sea.



Many orca hats were made and worn – there was a big pod out there at Fernfest! Next year, Superpod!

Fernfest 2016 Henry orca hat

Henry, orca hat model!

Fernfest 2016 Henry Kelly

Kelly and Henry at the Orca Month BC (Victoria) table

Fernfest 2016 Kelly mosaic

Kelly’s “Community” mosaic contribution

Fernfest 2016 orca hat remember Ruffles J1

An orca hat to remember J1 Ruffles

Fernfest 2016 Orca Friends

Yes, we are the orca people :-)


Orca Awareness Month Proclaimed in City of Victoria

Sorry about any ads. It’s WordPress, not me.



Orca Awareness Month


My speech to Victoria City Council May 26 (the 5 minute limit exactly!):

May 26/16
Mayor Helps and Council:

Good evening! My name is Diane McNally; I’m here to thank you for your recognition of the Attorney-General ‘s proclamation of June as the first Orca Awareness Month in British Columbia!

You are invited to Orca Month’s first event Saturday June 4, 9 am at the Songhees Wellness Centre. Songhees Nation Elder and master carver Clarence “Butch” Dick will speak to the history of the Lkwungen people, with a connection to the orcas in the waters bordering the territory. Birthday cake, coffee, tea, juice will be served at 10 in the Board Room to celebrate the orca babies born last year. Information about additional events is on the Orca Month BC facebook page and will be provided on June 4.

Orca Month BC will help raise awareness of the fact that, even though orcas’ intelligence equals ours, and they are the apex predator in these waters, carrying 3D mental maps of huge territories, they need protection – from us. In the decades around the 1950s orcas were often shot on sight as fish stealing man eaters. We discovered that they were highly intelligent and friendly when Moby Doll was harpooned and briefly exhibited in Vancouver in 1964 . A commercial capture for exhibit began, and came to a legislated end in 1976 as a result of public outcry based on the late Michael Bigg‘s research that proved population numbers were not as high as thought.

There are 4 main groups of orcas who live in and visit the Salish Sea: Southern residents, Northern residents, Transients (Bigg’s), and Offshores.All are listed as “threatened”, the Southern Residents only steps from from extinction.

Not much is known about the 250 Offshore orcas who range from California to Alaska in open water and are believed to eat fish and sharks They occasionally visit BC coastal and inshore waters, in large groups.

The transients, or Bigg’s orcas – named in memory of the late Michael Bigg – range from California to Alaska. They eat sea mammals and are the only species of whale that kills other whales. Their societies are matrilineal but adult children may leave their mother at maturity. They travel in small groups.

The Northern Residents, a fish eating group of about 250 individuals, range from South East Alaska to Washington State, travelling in family groups. The 83 Southern Residents are the most studied orca group in the world, a local extended family clan made up of matrilineal families in J, K and L pods , fish eaters who travel from central California to Haida Gwaii in the winter but spending summer and fall here in the Salish Sea.

Northern and Southern Residents’ ranges overlap to an extent but they never intermingle.

With only 83 Southern Residents left, we need to focus on how we can help keep local orcas from extinction.They face many challenges including humans taking huge numbers of their basic food, Chinook salmon, dammed spawning rivers, acoustic interference from ships and boats, disorientation and physical harm from Sonar used in military exercises and exploration. Pollutants discharged in to the Salish sea have resulted in male SRs and transient males’ bodies being designated toxic waste at death. Baby orcas often die before reaching 1 year old, as a result of stressors including the toxin offload from their mothers in milk.

The elder of the Resident orcas is Granny, J2, of J pod. At about 104 years old she has seen the world she grew up in, a much quieter ocean world with plentiful Chinook, disappear.

What can we do? We can:
• Support wild salmon stream restoration
• Institute more stringent limits on pollutant discharge and runoff into the Salish Sea
• Continue evaluating and improving guidelines for boat and ship activity
• Evaluate the potential for oil spills and take appropriate action
• Continue cross-border coordination for monitoring, research, and enforcement

On behalf of the orcas, thank you for recognizing Orca Awareness Month in BC.

banner orca month